51 Comments

Great, can't wait for the new release and flatpak version.

Expand full comment

Hi! I will absolutely be interestes to try the Beta Windows build:)

Expand full comment

I added updated beta packages for Windows for the latest release. Try them out and let me know if anything is off: https://github.com/alexkay/spek/releases/tag/v0.8.5

Expand full comment

I'm up for testing a macOS beta.

Expand full comment

I added an updated beta package of macOS for the latest release. Try it out and let me know if anything is off: https://github.com/alexkay/spek/releases/tag/v0.8.5

Expand full comment

Thanks. I'm afraid it crashes on launch. I can send you the crash report.

Expand full comment

I can reproduce it on a blank machine. I'll try to fix...

Expand full comment

Thomas, I updated the package. Could you try again?

Expand full comment

Now it no longer crashes.

As with previous versions I get this error message:

"Spek Warning

Cannot set locale to language "English (Denmark)"."

I've never seen that with other applications. And I don't remember seeing "English (Denmark)" anywhere else. Any idea what's causing it?

Expand full comment

I don't but I'll investigate. Does it work otherwise or it exits after that error?

Expand full comment

So far everything else seems fine.

Expand full comment

Thomas, could you add this as a new issue on GitHub? Please include what's shown in About this Mac -> System Report -> Software -> Language & Region.

Expand full comment

Sure. I'll add the issue.

Expand full comment

Waiting since 2014 for a windows version with "Faster Fast Fourier Transform"

Expand full comment

I added updated beta packages for Windows for the latest release. Try them out and let me know if anything is off: https://github.com/alexkay/spek/releases/tag/v0.8.5

Expand full comment

i wanna help :) i use win 10 on my desktop and monterey on my macbook pro m1

Expand full comment

I added updated beta packages for Windows for the latest release. Try them out and let me know if anything is off: https://github.com/alexkay/spek/releases/tag/v0.8.5

Expand full comment

just tried it on win10 (Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-9700K CPU @ 3.60GHz 3.60 GHz) , everything work including saving png picture :)

Expand full comment

Lovely, thank you Laurent!

Expand full comment

I also added a beta macOS package, could you give it a try?

Expand full comment

just got it to open (goddamn i hate apple's OS) IF FREAKING WORKS ! FINALY a SPEK that works on my m1 !!!!!! ok the time has come i said i would do a donation if you did it (work my m1 mac) how should i do that ? do you have a paypal link ?

Expand full comment

I'd love to beta test windows and mac builds.

Expand full comment

I added updated beta packages for Windows for the latest release. Try them out and let me know if anything is off: https://github.com/alexkay/spek/releases/tag/v0.8.5

Expand full comment

I tested the windows msi and zip on fully updated Windows 11 x64. Windows smartscreen gave a warning when the msi installer was launched, but did not block the install when I selected "Run anyway". Tested wav, mp3 320, and flac successfully. Screenshots: https://imgur.com/a/sRpECEI

Expand full comment

Great, thank you for testing, Isaac! The warning is expected until the installer is signed, I'll try to do it in a future version.

Expand full comment

I also added a beta macOS package, could you give it a try?

Expand full comment

Tested and working on Ventura on my intel macbook. :)

Expand full comment

Hi from a newbie

I have just tried analysing a few 24 bit 96000 wav files and they show up as 16 bit on the graphic. Have I some alteration to the setup yet to do? or is this the standard?

Expand full comment

I'm up for testing a macOS beta :-) (macOS Big Sur) Cheers!

Expand full comment

I added an updated beta package of macOS for the latest release. Try it out and let me know if anything is off: https://github.com/alexkay/spek/releases/tag/v0.8.5

Expand full comment

Many Thanks Alexander, unfortunately I have the same issue (When you open the dmg file the spek icon doesn't appear in the window in order slide it in application)

Expand full comment

Eva, I updated the package. Could you try again?

Expand full comment

Hi Alexander, unfortunately still the same issue (no spek logo to drag and drop in app after opening the dmg file) Cheers!

Expand full comment

Hi Alexander, I opened the dmg file on an old mac (OS Sierra) then I was able to copy the file generated on my new mac (OS Big Sur) and it seems working :-) Only one small issue the orange & red & purple waves is less easy to read than the previous colors (yellow, green etc...) Cheers

Expand full comment

Thank you for checking, Eva! You can change the palette by pressing "p": http://help.spek.cc/man-0.8.5.html

Expand full comment

Tested on Win11 last build, with i5-13600k, all fine!

Expand full comment

Hello! I just tried the v0.8.5 version on my Win11 laptop (i7-8750H) and it works fine!

Expand full comment

64 bits?

Expand full comment

Yes, the beta Windows binary is 64 bit.

Expand full comment

would Logmarithmic scale be in soon?

Expand full comment

No ETA but it's on the roadmap.

Expand full comment

POSSIBLE BUG: Latest WIN beta version doesn't seem to work with .dts files. Same audio track in an .mkv container does read/analyze. Older version used to work okay. Sample here: https://we.tl/t-m6fm3GLCyd and MediaInfo data for the audio file here: https://justpaste.it/cnwf0

SUGGESTIONS: 1) After reading initial analysis for multi-channel audio, if you switch channels, it has to start from scratch, even if you go back to an earlier channel, which was already analyzed in full before. Analysis could be stored in memory/cache instead of re-analyzing each time.

2) The w, W shortcut key for "Change the DFT window size." does not rotate back to lowest value but can only increase when pressed. Could be made to go back to start, similar to behaviour of other shortcut keys such as p or f.

Thank you so so so very much for continuing development and support for this amazing little tool! It is absolutely insane that free, light-weight software like this can take almost any filetype you throw at it, while paid professional software like Audition cannot! Keep it up fine sir! <3

Expand full comment

I can reproduce the .dts issue, thank you for sharing the sample, I'll investigate.

Caching analysis (or at least the decoded audio stream) is on the roadmap. It's the trade off between memory and performance.

Cycling with w/W works for me, what is your language and keyboard layout?

Thank you for the kind words!

Expand full comment

Thanks for quick response. Maybe could be a Preference switch for caching/memory/performance mode or something? For w/W cycling, my keyboard/language is US-English and I think I understand what's happening -- using W (capital) goes back to lower values and w goes up until max. But if you keep pressing either, it doesn't cycle around back to top/bottom, just stops at lowest/highest value. Whereas, p or f will keep coming back around, if you know what I mean? But all good, I get the usage of w/W now. Maybe works as intended. Cheers!

Expand full comment

Hi, 0.8.5. version is only for Win 64bit, but I'm still using, for objective reasons, Win7 Ultimate 32bit. There are any chances a 32 bit releases? Thank you.

Expand full comment